Grain & spawn 3 min read
Grain spawn bags vs jars: which should you use?
Jars are what everyone started with. Bags are what almost everyone ends up with. Here is why, and when a jar still wins.
The classic home-grow picture is a shelf of mason jars with foil lids. It still works. But the hobby moved to filter-patch bags for the same reasons commercial spawn makers use them, and if you are buying sterilised grain rather than making it, bags are what you will get. This is a fair comparison of the two so you understand what you are holding.
Sterility and gas exchange
A jar breathes through a hole in the lid stuffed with polyfill or covered with micropore tape. It works, but the filtration is improvised and the lid is a seal you made yourself. A bag breathes through a 0.2 micron filter patch laminated into the plastic, which is a laboratory-grade barrier, and it is heat-sealed above the patch. For gas exchange, bags win on both counts: better filtration and more of it, so the mycelium never runs short of oxygen in a big volume of grain.
Inoculation
Jars take a self-healing injection port in the lid, or a needle straight through micropore tape. Bags have the port built in. Both are fine with a syringe. For a wedge of agar or a grain-to-grain transfer, a jar is slightly easier to open and close cleanly on a bench, while a bag needs re-sealing with a fold and clip or an impulse sealer.
Shaking and breaking up
This is the big practical difference. Shaking a jar to distribute colonised kernels means swinging a glass jar hard enough to break clumps, and corn and wheat can set into a solid plug. A bag can be kneaded from the outside with your hands until every kernel is separate, which is gentler on the mycelium and far more thorough. It also means a 2kg bag is easy to handle; a 2kg jar is a brick.
Size and cost
Jars top out around a litre of grain, roughly 700g wet. Bags come in 1kg, 2kg and larger. For a tub that wants 2.5kg of spawn that is one or two bags against four jars. Jars are reusable, which keeps the cost of making your own grain low; bags are single use, which matters only if you are sterilising your own. If you buy sterilised grain, the bag is part of the product and the cost question disappears.
Where a jar still wins
- Small test batches. A jar of grain to check a new culture is cheaper than a bag.
- Seeing the bottom. Glass shows wet spot and contamination at the base better than plastic.
- Reuse. If you pressure cook your own grain every week, jars pay for themselves.
| Bags | Jars | |
|---|---|---|
| Filter | Laminated 0.2 micron patch | DIY polyfill or tape |
| Seal | Heat sealed | Lid you fitted |
| Break-up | Knead by hand, thorough | Shake hard, clumps |
| Size | 1kg to 5kg | Up to about 700g |
| Reuse | No | Yes |
| Buying pre-sterilised | Standard | Rare |
Our take
For spawn you buy, bags: that is what sterilised grain and colonised spawn come in, and it is why they colonise evenly and break up cleanly. For spawn you make yourself in small numbers, jars are a fine, frugal tool. Most growers end up with a few jars for tests and bags for everything that goes into a tub.
Questions people ask
Are grain bags better than jars?
For buying sterilised grain and for spawn you will mix into a tub, yes: better filtration, bigger sizes and much easier break-up. Jars remain handy for small test batches you sterilise yourself.
Can I reuse grain spawn bags?
No. The filter patch and seal are single use. Jars can be washed and reused.
How do I break up grain in a bag?
Knead it from the outside with both hands once it is at least a third colonised, until every kernel is separate. No need to open it.
Written by the Aus Myco Kingdom crew. Everything here is general growing information for gourmet and medicinal species; your room, your climate and your culture will have the final say.
Related guides
All guidesGrain & spawn 3 min read
Sterilised grain bags explained: what they are, how to use them and how to keep them clean
The injection port, the filter patch, the 2 to 5 ml, the three weeks. Everything a grain bag does and everything you do to it.
Grain & spawn 3 min read
Which grain is best for mushroom spawn? Wheat vs oats vs corn vs milo
Four grains, one standard. The differences are real but smaller than the forums suggest, and they mostly come down to kernel size.
Grain & spawn 3 min read
Grain spawn to substrate ratio: how much spawn you actually need
More spawn is faster and safer, less spawn is cheaper. Here is where the sweet spot sits for coir tubs and hardwood blocks, and a calculator that does the sums.
