Substrates 3 min read
Sterilisation vs pasteurisation: why our grain and substrate are autoclaved
Pasteurising thins the crowd. Sterilising clears the room. Which one a substrate needs depends on how much food is in it.
Every grow bag you buy says sterilised or pasteurised somewhere, and growers use the words loosely. They describe very different outcomes. Pasteurisation heats a substrate enough to kill most of the organisms in it while deliberately leaving some behind. Sterilisation kills everything, including bacterial endospores that survive boiling. Which one you need is decided by one question: how much nutrition is in the substrate for a competitor to eat?
Pasteurisation
Hold a substrate at 65 to 80°C for one to two hours, by soaking straw or coir in hot water or steaming it, and you kill the moulds, most bacteria and the insects and their eggs. You do not kill heat-tolerant bacterial spores. The theory, and it works, is that the survivors are mostly beneficial or harmless, and that a nutrient-poor substrate like plain straw or plain coir does not give the survivors enough to eat to outrun a vigorous mushroom spawn. Pasteurisation is cheap, quick and does not need pressure, and for plain, unsupplemented bulk material it is enough.
Sterilisation
Hold a substrate at 121°C (15 psi in a pressure cooker or autoclave) for long enough for the heat to penetrate to the centre, typically 90 minutes for a jar of grain and two to three hours for a 2 to 5kg bag, and you kill everything, spores included. The substrate is now inert: nothing in it is alive until you add your culture. Sterilisation needs pressure, time and a filter-patch bag to keep the sterile contents sterile, which is why it is a lab job rather than a kitchen one.
Why grain must be sterilised
Grain is food. Hydrated wheat or oats will grow bacteria overnight, and the bacteria that survive pasteurisation (the endospore formers) are exactly the ones that cause wet spot: slimy, sour, grey kernels that never colonise. There is no pasteurised grain spawn for that reason. Every grain bag and all-in-one we sell has been through a full autoclave cycle.
Why supplemented substrate must be sterilised
Plain coir can be pasteurised because there is nothing in it worth eating. The moment you add bran, soy hulls, worm castings, hardwood pellets with supplement, or minerals, you have made a substrate that mould and bacteria can colonise as fast as your mushroom can, and pasteurisation leaves survivors that will. Our CVA, CVWA and wood lovers substrates are all supplemented for yield, and all are sterilised, because the alternative is a green tub.
| Pasteurisation | Sterilisation | |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature | 65 to 80°C | 121°C under pressure |
| Kills | Moulds, most bacteria, insects | Everything, including spores |
| Leaves | Beneficial and harmless survivors | Nothing alive |
| Needs | Hot water or steam | Pressure vessel, filter-patch bags |
| Enough for | Plain straw, plain coir | Grain, supplemented substrate, agar |
What this means for you
- A sterilised bag is only sterile while sealed. Every opening is a chance for a spore to land, which is why spawning happens in a still air box.
- You cannot "re-sterilise" by microwaving or boiling. Neither reaches the temperature or the pressure. If a bag is contaminated, it is a bin bag.
- Pasteurised products are not inferior, they are for different materials. A bag of plain pasteurised straw is a fine oyster substrate. A bag of pasteurised supplemented sawdust is a gamble.
Questions people ask
Is pasteurised substrate good enough?
For plain straw or plain coir with no supplement, yes. For grain or any supplemented substrate, no: the survivors will eat the supplement before your mycelium can.
Can I sterilise substrate in the oven or microwave?
No. Neither reaches 121°C under pressure, and dry heat does not penetrate wet substrate. Sterilisation needs a pressure vessel.
How do I know a bag was really sterilised?
An uninoculated sealed bag that stays unchanged for weeks, with no swelling, colour or smell, was sterile. Any growth in a sealed bag before inoculation means it was not.
Written by the Aus Myco Kingdom crew. Everything here is general growing information for gourmet and medicinal species; your room, your climate and your culture will have the final say.
Related guides
All guidesSubstrates 3 min read
Mushroom substrate guide: coir, hardwood and the right one for every species
Substrate is dinner. Oysters will eat almost anything; lion's mane and shiitake want wood. Match the menu to the species and most problems never happen.
Substrates 3 min read
Coco coir mushroom substrate (CVA): what is in it, who it suits and how to run a tub
Coir is the substrate that made home growing easy: clean, cheap, forgiving and endlessly thirsty. Here is what our CVA blend adds and how to use a bag of it.
Substrates 3 min read
Hardwood pellet substrate for wood lovers: lion's mane, shiitake, king oyster and reishi
Lion's mane on a coir tub is a disappointment. Lion's mane on a hardwood block is a revelation. The difference is dinner.
